Lately, I’ve been reflecting on the beauty of unity within diversity or even difference in the church – and the need for us to uphold it and even fight for it. Maybe it’s because the world feels increasingly divided and polarised right now, but I believe the church has a wonderful opportunity to demonstrate a different way of living – one where we can hold firmly to our convictions while genuinely loving, respecting, and partnering with those who see things differently.
In Ephesians 4, Paul urges us to “Make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit through the bond of peace.” I have been thinking about what it actually means to make every effort to maintain unity, particularly when we disagree.
Across our church streams, and even within denominations, there are issues that can divide us. For some, baptism is the defining issue. For others, it may be worship styles or gender roles in church leadership. Of course, these issues are significant and we need to give them proper reflection and dialogue. However, not every theological issue carries the same weight. There are primary issues that are foundational to the Christian faith, and secondary issues, where sincere Christians may reach different conclusions while remaining united in their commitment to Christ. And when that happen the important question becomes not simply what we disagree about, but how we disagree.
If we are called to “make every effort to keep the unity of the Spirit”, then that means straining every sinew to maintain unity with brothers and sisters with whom we disagree.
For me that means resisting the temptation to turn every theological conversation into an attempt to convince, cajole, or win someone over to my own point of view. It means learning to rejoice together in the fundamentals of our faith, in the truths we share, and in the historic creeds that unite Christians across traditions, but also learning to hold our convictions on secondary matters without insisting that everyone else must share them. It might mean learning to hold our tongues or disagreeing agreeably, without forcing our own way. It means being willing to learn from others, where we discover that those who approach Scripture differently may have something valuable to teach us. Humility requires us to recognise that our own understanding is not exhaustive and that we can benefit from the perspectives of other Christians.
In my own denomination, we may share a common heritage and confession of faith but can still hold distinct convictions on secondary – and it’s actually something I deeply appreciate when we can learn to work together, serve together, and support one another despite those differences.
I have come to believe that unity in disagreement can be a source of strength. Indeed, I believe that denominational differences are actually positive when it comes to the church’s mission, because different churches reach different people and connect with different communities. And so, we can rejoice in the fruitfulness and success of churches that don’t look like ours, worship like ours, or share all our convictions.
Unity does not mean uniformity. That does not require me to abandon my convictions or pretend that difference doesn’t exist. But it recognises that shared identity in Christ is greater than the differences that might otherwise keep us apart.
So maybe one of the most powerful testimonies we as the church can offer in a divided and polarised world is not that we all think alike, worship alike, or organise ourselves in exactly the same way, but that we can remain united in Christ while embracing the richness of our differences.
In essentials, unity; in non-essentials, liberty; in all things, charity











Recent Comments